Site Logotype
News

Gary Lineker returns to BBC for first time since post likening supporters of Israel to rats as host fronts FA Cup final

Gary Lineker, the former England striker and long-serving presenter of the BBC’s “Match of the Day,” returned to television screens to host the FA Cup final between Manchester City and Crystal Palace at Wembley. This appearance marked his first since a recent controversy surrounding a social media post that was widely criticized as antisemitic. The incident has reignited debates over impartiality, social media use by public figures, and the responsibilities of broadcasters.

The Controversial Post

On May 12, 2025, Lineker shared an Instagram story featuring a video titled “Zionism explained in two minutes,” accompanied by an image of a rat. The rat, historically used in antisemitic propaganda, particularly by Nazi Germany, drew immediate backlash. Lineker deleted the post upon realizing its offensive nature and issued an unreserved apology, stating

“I very much regret these references. I would never knowingly share anything antisemitic. It goes against everything I believe in.”

Despite the apology, the incident led to public outrage and calls for disciplinary action. The Metropolitan Police received multiple complaints and are assessing whether further action is necessary.

BBC’s Response and Impartiality Guidelines

The BBC, emphasizing its commitment to impartiality, responded to the controversy by highlighting the importance of adhering to its social media guidelines. Director-General Tim Davie stated

“The BBC’s reputation is held by everyone, and when someone makes a mistake, it costs us. We absolutely need people to be exemplars of BBC values and follow our social media policies.”

In response to previous incidents involving Lineker, the BBC had already implemented stricter social media guidelines, often referred to as the “Lineker clause.” These rules restrict high-profile presenters from expressing political views on social media, especially when their programs are on air or during election periods.

Lineker’s Career and Departure from “Match of the Day”

Lineker has been a prominent figure in sports broadcasting, hosting “Match of the Day” since the late 1990s. In November 2024, he announced his intention to step down from the program at the end of the 2024-25 Premier League season. However, following the recent controversy, it was confirmed that his final appearance would be on May 25, 2025.

Despite stepping down from “Match of the Day,” Lineker is expected to continue his association with the BBC by presenting coverage of major football events, including the FA Cup and the 2026 World Cup.

Public and Media Reaction

The incident has sparked widespread debate about the responsibilities of public figures on social media. While some have defended Lineker, citing his prompt apology and history of humanitarian advocacy, others have criticized the BBC for not taking more decisive action. The Campaign Against Antisemitism called for Lineker’s dismissal, questioning the sincerity of his apology.

Conclusion

Gary Lineker’s return to the BBC amid the recent controversy highlights the ongoing challenges faced by public broadcasters in balancing freedom of expression with impartiality. As social media continues to blur the lines between personal and professional spheres, institutions like the BBC must navigate these complexities to maintain public trust and uphold their values.

Jack Williams
Share